Article/Publication Details

Why Do We Need Vitalism? Canguilhem’s Reinterpretation of One Concept

(Original title: Načo potrebujeme vitalizmus? Canguilhemova reinterpretácia jedného pojmu)
Filozofia, 2015, vol. 70, No 1, pp. 13-22.
Language: Slovak
File to download: PDF*
BibTex EndNote Tagged EndNote XML RIS

Document Statistics:

Number of visits: 1,520
Number of visits today: 0
Last visit: 20.10.2019 - 04:23
PDF downloads: 415


The paper concerns a specific defence of vitalism in Georges Canguilhem’s essay “Aspects of Vitalism.” Canguilhem suggests that vitalism is not a scientific doctrine, but rather a demand or a claim of irreducibility of the living. Canguilhem even signifies it as an ethics (because the sphere of values is essential here for understanding vital phenomena). On the contrary, mechanicism as a common name for all conceptions hostile to vitalism is in fact a basic method (in terms of a way or an attitude) of scientific work. The relation between these antagonisms takes often a form of a struggle. The first chapter of the article grasps the topic of life and the vitality of vitalism. The second one is a consideration on inspirational and resistant features of vitalism. The last chapter gives an explication of the scientific and the pre-scientific and of valorization of vital phenomena. Although Canguilhemian “vitalism” as a demand cannot be labeled as science, it is still the reverse side of scientific work based primarily on mere naturalistic attitude.


G. Canguilhem, Life, Mechanicism, Scientific reductionism, Vitalism

*The article is subject to copyright.